When anyone mentions Scotland, the first thoughts are of the splendour of the mountains and the views across the lochs. The weather can change in an instant, with the possibility of snow, rain, wind and sun within a twenty four hour period. Unfortunately, these beautiful images may soon be just a memory as companies promoting green technology are attempting to buy as much land as possible in order to develop large numbers of onshore wind farms. The developers are desperate to benefit from the large taxpayer subsidies and are attempting to encourage local communities to support them by offering significant incentives.
Several groups are giving evidence to Holyrood’s Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. Ramblers Scotland say that… “safeguards in the planning system to protect sensitive areas being ignored.” They have asked for a reduction in the subsidies which should then slow down the numbers of onshore developments. Their written submission to the enquiry continues “Planning authorities, public agencies, local communities and interest groups are overwhelmed by the number of planning applications for wind farm development that are coming forward.”
Communities Against Turbines Scotland are planning a protest march in Edinburgh next week with Donald Trump. Mr Trump will be in Scotland to attend the same enquiry in which he has opposed plans for the building of an offshore wind farm which will be located off the coast from his Aberdeenshire golf resort.
The major problem appears to stem from the desire of Alex Salmond that all of Scotland’s electricity should be from renewable resources by the end of 2020. Ramblers Scotland, which has 6,500 members say “the levels of inducement being offered to local communities to get permission for wind farms on their land is ‘little short of bribery’ and putting the integrity of the planning system at risk.” They further commented that “all households are paying for this largesse through increased electricity bills” and concluded “the situation can be summed up simply as ‘never in the history of public subsidy has so much been given to so few for so little public benefit’.”
The chairman of a community council in Cameron, Fife, Gordon Ball, has criticised Scottish ministers “for failing to understand the concerns of local communities and warned residents have been left powerless to stop a green energy policy.” He added “Targets and subsidies drive the market and these are massive forces. By relying on the market and incentivising those who want to erect wind turbines to force the pace, it has left local communities feeling disenfranchise and disconnected from the processes that shape their lives.”
Scottish Renewables which represents the green energy companies concluded by stating that “its members only receive financial support when they begin to generate clean electricity, not for building wind farms. Community benefit is an entirely voluntary gesture and not a material consideration for the planning authority when making a decision on a wind farm.”

